[Feedback] Forum Reorganization

[Panda-chan]

^ That has nothing to do with the layout and everything to do with the lack of members. I'm sure that when activity picks up again on the site, the new members are going to be super intimidated by the sheer amount of topics in every single forum.

Look at the Den for example. The sub-forums in the Den are the only thing that give it any semblance of organization. If you were to merge literally everything off-topic into one mega forum like you are suggesting, it'd be an insane amount of topics lumped together with no way to find anything. No new member would ever want to sift through all that to find something worth posting in, just to have it be drowned out by What are you thinking/eating/drinking/whining/breathing RN????? trashposts (because lets be honest, 99% of the time this is what gets bumped to the top).

[FlipMode]

^ That has nothing to do with the layout and everything to do with the lack of members. I'm sure that when activity picks up again on the site, the new members are going to be super intimidated by the sheer amount of topics in every single forum.

Look at the Den for example. The sub-forums in the Den are the only thing that give it any semblance of organization. If you were to merge literally everything off-topic into one mega forum like you are suggesting, it'd be an insane amount of topics lumped together with no way to find anything. No new member would ever want to sift through all that to find something worth posting in, just to have it be drowned out by What are you thinking/eating/drinking/whining/breathing RN????? trashposts (because lets be honest, 99% of the time this is what gets bumped to the top).

Yeah but all the trash posts would be in the random or forum games section in the layout I suggested. And Member chat type threads and personal issues etc to be in the forum lounge. So its actually easier to find threads you might want to post in.
If you're acknowledging that there's a lot of spam in The Den, then why not have a dedicated area to move it to? I swear we used to have it and it was called The Arcade or something, worked fine.

I agree with the first point you made. Its lack of members caused by years of crappy drama, trashposting, lite trolling, spam etc and some quite frankly baffling decisions from the staff team that drove others away.

But I say try and make it as simpler and condensed as you can, because the layout we have now and even the one Az suggested really is still too much, its kinda still the same but without the really dead sections.
Try a drastically different layout and see how it goes. Because if you don't learn from your past, you're sure to repeat it.

Look at something like Reddit, the most popular forums online. You have one place to discuss everything related to the subject matter and that's the lot. I find it way better and easier but that could just be me.

[Azdgari]

To be honest with you guys I still don't think you're really going after what the real problem is.

Can you clarify on that bit?

#deleteeverythingexceptforthelionkingsectionsandmaybememberhq

This brutha gets it.

To be honest with you guys I still don't think you're really going after what the real problem is. But if you're going to reorganise the boards then I've been thinking about it and what I would have is...

Going from Flip's original layout, how about this? Mostly the same, just a small handful of things broken out slightly more.

The Kingdom

Lion King
Lion King 2
Lion King 1.5
Lion Guard
Lion King Remake
Beyond the Lion King (encompasses creators, broadway, all other LK-related material)


Website & Forum
Announcements
+MLK Radio, if Silly's feelin' it
Introductions
Feedback / How To
Member Lounge
+Personal Issues and Support (a lot of people have requested to keep this subsection)

Creativity
Fan Fiction
Fan Art and Media
Roleplay

Off Topic
Off Topic Creativity (off-topic RPs, fanfiction, art, etc)
Forum Games
The Watering Hole (encompasses all other off-topic discussion)

[MalibuTrashDog]

trash

U talking about me >8(

[Azdgari]

Howdy everyone--planning on making this happen over the weekend. If you have any input, make it known now: because of the nature of merging forums, it will be fairly permanent in the sense that we won't be able to 're-separate' forums that are merged (without manually digging through all the topics and moving them, which is not particularly feasible).

[Tora]

Howdy everyone--planning on making this happen over the weekend. If you have any input, make it known now: because of the nature of merging forums, it will be fairly permanent in the sense that we won't be able to 're-separate' forums that are merged (without manually digging through all the topics and moving them, which is not particularly feasible).

So is the Den going to be the watering hole now then?

[Azdgari]

Haha, that was really just an off the cuff suggestion. I’m indifferent—and since that’s just the forum name, that is very easy to change back and forth.

[FlipMode]

I'm just here to wait until it's done and then tell you how much I hate it

[DGFone]

Why do I feel like forum reorganization is going to end up in a "they changed it so now it sucks" situation, no matter the changes?

[Azdgari]

Well, you can't say we didn't ask for input.