by DGFone » October 18th, 2012, 6:48 am
Taka, at best, is a failure that turns into Scar. The only information we have about him has its cannonity (if that's a word) disputed by everyone, with many regarding it as non-canon, or semi-canon at best.
As bad as Scar is, we at least know him. He is an official character, and we can guess what he will do given a situation. Plus, he is voiced by Jeremy Irons. Not many can beat that. So... Scar wins.