Zira v Scar

[Scars Mate]

Who do you like better? I have to say Scar... But I was wondering what you guys think

[InsaneSeagull]

Scar by far. He's awesome, hot and actually meaningful! And has an awesome voice, I have to add!

[Scars Mate]

[quote="KristinaKiara"]Scar by far. He's awesome, hot and actually meaningful! And has an awesome voice, I have to add![/quote]
My thoughts exactly! Thank god I'm not the only one who has a crush on him!

[TheLionPrince]

Well, let's see...

Scar was willing and able to murder his own, close family members including his own nephew, and he traumatized him for life by stating he was responsible for his father's death. To add more fuel to the fire, he attempted to kill with his nephew twice (as a child and as an adult). There's a reason why Scar is called Scar, and it's more than just the scar over his eye. It's because he is the scar to Simba's life, and unlike the scars that heal after in a couple of weeks, the scar on his nephew's life continued for years and years. And even after death, his impact on Simba's life still lives on as depicted in his nightmare. Back to the movie, he reigns on high as an evil king for a number of years, and intends to let the pride starve to death. Anyway, for all we know Scar is a narcissist (remember when he sings he wishes to be "Respected, saluted. And seen for the wonder I am"), and full of bitterness, greed, and jealously.

Zira was bloodthirsty, but she hadn't really accomplished much of anything evil after she was exiled. This wrongful exile and Simba killing her obsessive love interest, Scar, sends her into devising a murderous plan for which she robs her own son of his childhood by training him into committing regicide. In the end, she too is shown to be willing to kill another of her children, and resisted help when she needed it the most. Anyway, I am more incline to believe her insanity and hatefulness of anything Pridelander-ish deepened throughout the years.

Much like Zira, Scar's character is not given much of a backstory. So, it is left to the audiences that he was second-in-line for the throne, only to be push third-in-line. In the end, Scar accomplished more evil acts than Zira ever did. Zira wasn't a child murderer, and didn't commit any evil acts for greed and jealousy but for revenge, as in she had more of "justification" even though she did not go too far with her master plan. Also take note, her emotional impact on Kovu's life wasn't as severe as Scar's impact on Simba's life.

So, in my opinion, Scar is the better villain.

[ScarsLove]

[quote="UruSarabiNala"][quote="KristinaKiara"]Scar by far. He's awesome, hot and actually meaningful! And has an awesome voice, I have to add![/quote]
My thoughts exactly! Thank god I'm not the only one who has a crush on him![/quote]
Who says you two are the only ones with a crush on him

Back to the topic, I would have to say Scar. And TheLionPrince pretty much sums up my opinion why.

[Ozy]

Scar. I mean that lion-goatee? Rawr!

[iippu]

i put both xD but i like more scar

[AdAstrα]

Scar.

[The Demonic Weasel]

[quote="Wolf Song"][size=75][quote="UruSarabiNala"][quote="KristinaKiara"]Scar by far. He's awesome, hot and actually meaningful! And has an awesome voice, I have to add![/quote]
My thoughts exactly! Thank god I'm not the only one who has a crush on him![/quote]
Who says you two are the only ones with a crush on him
[/quote]

I'm with you guys on this point. >3

Anyway, I love both Scar and Zira! They're my two favorite TLK characters. I'm going to say I like Scar best, but that's probably because I'm a girl and girls tend to like guy characters best. xP There's something very charismatic about him. I love Zira though too. <3

[Ananda]

Zira is a legend. I like Scar as well.